Cazes LawBLG | Business Law Group 405.254.5005

QSub election in a deal: how we think about Form 8869

Cazes Law Editorial · · 10 min read

An S corporation that buys another corporation, or that reorganizes under a new holding company, ends up owning stock in a subsidiary. Federal tax law then hands the parent a choice: leave the subsidiary as a separate corporation, or make a QSub election on Form 8869 and have the subsidiary disappear for income-tax purposes. The form is one page. The consequences aren't.

Here's how we think about the decision points, in the order they tend to come up for a closely held Oklahoma S corporation and the CPAs advising it.

What a QSub election actually does

A qualified subchapter S subsidiary, or QSub, is a domestic corporation that isn't an ineligible corporation, where the S corporation holds 100 percent of its stock and elects to treat it as a QSub. That's the statutory definition in section 1361(b)(3)(B). Every word of it comes back later.

Once the election is in, the statute says the QSub "shall not be treated as a separate corporation." Its assets, liabilities, and items of income, deduction, and credit are treated as the parent's. One return. One pass-through.

The mechanism that gets you there is a deemed liquidation. Under the regulations, the subsidiary is deemed to have liquidated into the S corporation, and the Form 8869 instructions say so in plain terms. That deemed liquidation is the entire tax event, and whether it's quiet or loud depends on what else happened around it.

Decision one: QSub versus single-member LLC subsidiary

Start with whether the subsidiary needs to be a corporation at all. A single-member LLC owned by the S corporation is generally disregarded for federal income-tax purposes too, and it doesn't depend on an election that can be lost.

The QSub route tends to win when the subsidiary already exists as a corporation with things attached to its charter that nobody wants to disturb: licenses, contracts with anti-assignment clauses, lender relationships. Converting it to an LLC under state law is a legal change with its own tax analysis. A QSub election leaves the state-law corporation where it is and changes only the federal tax picture.

An LLC subsidiary tends to win when the structure is built from scratch, or when the parent might later admit a shareholder who can't hold S corporation stock. A QSub lives and dies with the parent's S election. A disregarded LLC doesn't.

Both forms of subsidiary remain separate entities under state law, so liability isolation doesn't favor one over the other. What does: the QSub rules carry a five-year penalty box for a terminated election, which we'll get to, and the LLC rules don't.

Decision two: timing the effective date

The regulations let the parent make the election at any time during the taxable year, but the date it takes effect is boxed in. The date written on the form can't be more than two months and 15 days before the filing date, and it can't be more than 12 months after it.

Miss the box and the regulation moves your date. Too far in the past, and the election becomes effective two months and 15 days before filing. Too far out, and it becomes effective 12 months after filing.

Revocations run on the same limits. And there's a small, useful wrinkle in the regulation: a revocation that takes effect on the very first day the QSub election was going to be effective isn't treated as a termination for the five-year rule. If a plan changes between signing the form and the effective date, that's the clean exit.

Here's the practitioner's edge on timing. In an acquisition, the deemed liquidation doesn't happen at the close of the day before the effective date, which is the general rule. The regulations say that when the parent doesn't own 100 percent of the stock on the day before the election is effective, the liquidation occurs immediately after the moment the parent first owns 100 percent. So the closing date and the date on line 11 of Form 8869 have to tell the same story, and in our experience line 11 is the item on the closing checklist most likely to be filled in by someone who wasn't in the room when the structure was decided.

One more point from the instructions: Form 8869 goes to the service center where the subsidiary filed its most recent return, not the parent's, unless the election is effective on formation of a subsidiary the parent created.

Decision three: the deemed liquidation inside an acquisition

This is where the QSub election stops being a filing and becomes a structuring question. The regulation says the tax treatment of the liquidation, or of a larger transaction that includes the liquidation, is determined under the Code and general principles of tax law, "including the step transaction doctrine."

The step transaction doctrine is the principle that formally separate steps can be collapsed and taxed as one transaction when they're really one plan. Its presence in the regulation means the stock purchase and the QSub election can be looked at together.

Two examples in the regulations show the fork. In the first, an S corporation buys all the stock of a target corporation and then makes a QSub election. The regulation treats the liquidation as an independent step separate from the stock acquisition, and the tax consequences of the liquidation are determined under sections 332 and 337, the provisions that generally make a parent-subsidiary liquidation nontaxable. The buyer ends up holding the target's assets inside its own S corporation.

A later example in the same regulation shows the other path. The buyer makes a qualified stock purchase of an S corporation, the parties make a section 338(h)(10) election, and a QSub election is made effective the next day. There, the target is treated as having sold all of its assets at the close of the acquisition date, and the liquidation occurs immediately after the deemed asset purchase by the new corporation.

That contrast is the heart of the decision. A buyer who wants asset-level treatment of the purchase price, with everything that implies for the seller's tax bill, has to get there through a vehicle the regulations recognize for that purpose, such as the section 338(h)(10) route the example describes. A QSub election by itself doesn't do that; it changes what the subsidiary is, not what the buyer paid for. Both sides should know which example their deal resembles before the purchase agreement is drafted, because buyer and seller economics pull in opposite directions on this exact point.

Form 8869 also covers the holding-company version. Line 14 is checked "Yes" when the election is made pursuant to a reorganization under section 368(a)(1)(F) of the kind described in Rev. Rul. 2008-18, where a newly formed parent holds the stock of the former operating S corporation, and the instructions say no Form 2553 is required from the parent. Sellers often arrive with this structure in place, and the buyer's advisors need to see how it was filed.

Decision four: the termination trap

Remember that definition: 100 percent of the stock, held by an S corporation. The regulations say the election terminates on a revocation's effective date, at the close of the parent's last S corporation taxable year if the parent's S election ends, or at the close of the day an event occurs that makes the subsidiary ineligible.

The consequence is spelled out in the statute. On termination, the former QSub is treated as a new corporation acquiring all of its assets and assuming its liabilities immediately before the cessation, in exchange for its stock. The statute goes further for stock sales: where the termination comes from a sale of stock, the sale is treated as a sale of an undivided interest in the subsidiary's assets, followed by a transfer of all the assets and liabilities to the subsidiary in a transaction to which section 351 applies.

One example in the regulations is the one every S corporation owner with a QSub should keep in mind. The parent sells 21 percent of the QSub's stock to an unrelated corporation for cash. The election terminates. The deemed exchange does not qualify under section 351 because the parent is no longer in control of the subsidiary, and the parent may have to recognize gain on the assets deemed transferred.

In practice, this is how the problem surfaces: nobody set out to terminate a QSub election. Someone offered a minority stake to a key manager, or brought in an outside investor at the subsidiary level, or let a shareholder of the parent transfer parent stock into a trust that doesn't qualify to hold it. That last one kills the parent's S election, and the QSub election goes with it. (The elections that keep S stock safe in a trust have their own set of rules.) The tax bill arrives at the parent level, on assets the parent thought it still owned outright.

There's paperwork too. When an event terminates the election, the regulation requires the parent to attach to its return for that year a notification that the QSub election has terminated, identifying both companies and the date.

In fairness to the rule, it isn't hidden. It follows from the definition, because the whole QSub regime rests on one S corporation owning everything. The moment that stops being true, the regime lets go, and the Code says how.

Decision five: the five-year bar and the regulatory escape

After a termination, the statute bars the corporation, and any successor, from a new QSub election or an S election before its fifth taxable year beginning after the first year the termination was effective, unless the Secretary consents. The regulations put the burden on the corporation to show why consent should be given.

The escape is in the same regulation. Consent isn't required if, immediately after the termination, the corporation is otherwise eligible to make an S election or have a QSub election made for it, and the new election is effective immediately after the termination.

In a deal, that looks like an S corporation selling 100 percent of its QSub's stock to another S corporation that makes its own QSub election effective immediately after closing. Or the former QSub makes an S election effective the moment it ceases to be a QSub. Either way, no consent is needed. There can be no gap; even a short one puts the corporation back in front of the five-year rule.

The escape doesn't help in a partial sale. Sell 21 percent and the subsidiary isn't eligible to be anyone's QSub, and it can't elect S status unless every new shareholder qualifies. That scenario earns the full five years or a consent request.

Decision six: when the election is late

Form 8869's instructions are blunt about lateness. An election filed more than two months and 15 days after the requested effective date is generally late, and the IRS will generally make it effective two months and 15 days before the filing date unless the corporation shows reasonable cause for the delay.

For a parent that discovers the problem later, Rev. Proc. 2013-30 provides the standard relief route for late QSub elections, alongside late S corporation, QSST, and ESBT elections. The request must be made within three years and 75 days after the intended effective date. The parent files a completed Form 8869 with "FILED PURSUANT TO REV. PROC. 2013-30" at the top and a statement explaining the reasonable cause or inadvertence and the diligent steps taken to correct it once discovered. The revenue procedure says its user fees don't apply to corrective actions under it.

Outside that window, or if relief is denied, the IRS's late-election page says the entity may request a private letter ruling under the IRS's annual ruling procedures. The same procedure governs a late Form 2553, and the two problems travel together: a parent that never filed its own S election can't have a valid QSub election either.

How does a QSub election go unfiled in the first place? Usually because everyone at closing assumed someone else owned the form. Counsel thought the CPA was filing it with the first return; the CPA thought it was a closing document. Nobody checked.

The Oklahoma angle

Most of the S corporations we see are closely held Oklahoma companies, and the QSub question arrives in two situations: an owner buying a competitor that's also an S corporation, and an owner putting a holding company over an operating business ahead of a sale or a generational transfer. In both, the federal rules above decide whether the deemed liquidation is a nonevent or a recognition event.

What we haven't sourced here is Oklahoma's own income-tax treatment of the deemed liquidation, of QSub reporting, or of the parent's state return afterward. That should be checked against the Oklahoma Tax Commission's current rules before anyone relies on the federal answer, and we'd rather say so than guess. The same goes for any other state where the subsidiary files.

The entity-level choices that lead up to a QSub election, including whether a holding-company structure makes sense at all, are covered in our piece on converting your entity.

When a lawyer becomes cheaper than the mistake

A QSub error compounds through every return filed afterward. The point where we'd want counsel involved is before the purchase agreement is signed, when the deal can still be built around the example in the regulations the parties actually want rather than the one they stumbled into. The second point is the day anyone proposes selling or issuing a single share of a QSub.

If your S corporation is acquiring another corporation, restructuring under a holding company, or has a subsidiary whose ownership is about to change, reach us through the contact page or our Oklahoma City office. A conversation before closing is almost always less expensive than unwinding a terminated election after the fact.

Sources

  1. 26 U.S.C. § 1361 - S corporation defined (LII)
  2. 26 CFR § 1.1361-3 - QSub election (LII)
  3. 26 CFR § 1.1361-4 - Effect of QSub election (LII)
  4. 26 CFR § 1.1361-5 - Termination of QSub election (LII)
  5. Instructions for Form 8869, Qualified Subchapter S Subsidiary Election (IRS)
  6. Internal Revenue Bulletin 2013-36 (Rev. Proc. 2013-30)
  7. Late Election Relief (IRS)

This article is general information about Oklahoma, Texas, and federal law, not legal advice, and it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Facts matter; talk to a lawyer about yours.