Cazes LawBLG | Business Law Group 405.254.5005

Oklahoma sales tax on advertising: anatomy of one campaign

Cazes Law Editorial · · 11 min read

A marketing campaign arrives at the bookkeeper's desk as a stack of unrelated invoices. An agency bill. A media buy. A printer's invoice with postage on a separate line. A box of branded calendars. A mail-house statement with a jurisdiction report stapled to it.

Oklahoma sales tax on advertising treats each of those pieces differently, and the differences don't follow the campaign's logic. They follow an older test: whether tangible personal property changed hands, and if so, where it was delivered. Below we walk one generic campaign in the order the bills show up, using the Tax Commission's own rules.

Two housekeeping points first. We're describing Oklahoma rules only, and where a rule points to the Sales Tax Code we'll say so rather than quote section numbers.

Invoice one: the agency's creative and strategy fee

The campaign starts with an agency that develops the concept, writes the copy, and designs the pieces. Its invoice reads like a service bill, because it is one.

Under the Tax Commission's rule on advertising agencies, OAC 710:65-19-2, the agency is the consumer of the materials it buys to do that work. Drawing supplies, photographic supplies, and office supplies are taxed to the agency when the agency buys them. When the agency passes the resulting materials on to its client, that transfer isn't taxed.

Nothing in the rule mentions the agency's fee to its client. Our reading, which the letter ruling discussed below reaches on similar facts, is that a bill for strategy and creative is a charge for a service the Sales Tax Code doesn't list, so it carries no Oklahoma sales tax while the agency absorbs the tax on its own inputs. The effect is to tax the raw materials once, at the agency level, rather than taxing the finished idea.

The same rule adds a second limb that matters later in this story. When an agency sells items like letterhead and business cards, it is treated under the printer rules for those sales. An agency that moves from selling ideas to selling printed deliverables has changed what it is for sales tax purposes, even if the invoice header never changes.

Invoice two: Oklahoma sales tax on advertising space and time

Next comes the media buy. The campaign places ads in a newspaper, on a billboard, in a broadcast slot, and on a website.

OAC 710:65-13-1 exempts sales of advertising space across that whole list: newspapers, periodicals, programs for sporting and entertainment events, billboards and similar outdoor surfaces, and internet and electronic media including radio, television, cable, and satellite. The rule also covers the servicing of advertising devices. Its most recent amendment on the page we read is effective September 14, 2018.

Subsection (b) is the part buyers skip. The purchase of materials and equipment used to produce the advertisement is taxable. The rule gives no examples, but on its wording the airtime is exempt while the camera, the set dressing, the printed proofs, and the vinyl for the billboard face are not.

Then subsection (c) adds a condition on the newspaper and periodical side. Advertising in a newspaper or periodical gets the exemption only if the publication is generally recognized as a newspaper, or is a periodical as the rule cites the Sales Tax Code's definition. A shopper tabloid or a trade sheet that looks like a newspaper may or may not be one.

What counts as a newspaper or periodical

For that question the Commission's companion rule, OAC 710:65-13-190, does the work. It says the statute doesn't define either term. A newspaper, in the rule's words, is a paper printed and distributed at a regular and usually short interval that contains news, opinion, features, advertising, or other matter of current interest.

Periodicals get a longer treatment. The rule leans on an Oklahoma Supreme Court decision, Swap and Shop Advertiser v. Oklahoma Tax Commission, and sets a periodicity test: the publication must appear periodically and more than once a year. Weekly, monthly, quarterly, and semiannual all qualify. Secondary considerations follow in declining weight: general-public rather than specialized content, a magazine format, availability by subscription, general advertising, and common acceptance as a magazine.

Each issue also has to stand alone; loose-leaf update packets that combine into a book don't qualify.

Invoice three: the print run

Now the campaign gets physical. Brochures, postcards, and a short catalog come off a press, and the printer's invoice is the first one on the stack that carries Oklahoma sales tax by default.

OAC 710:65-19-265 is blunt: gross receipts from the sales of printed matter of all kinds are subject to the sales tax. The rule lists catalogs, books, and clothing with printing on it as examples. Printing labor can't be subtracted from the taxable price even when it's billed on a separate line, and printing on stock the customer supplies is taxable too.

The pre-press line items

Typesetting, color separation, design, art, and camera work invoiced to a customer who isn't a manufacturer are taxable under subsection (b), even if separately stated. This is where the agency rule and the printer rule meet. Design sold as part of an agency's idea work is untaxed; the same design sold by a printer to a non-manufacturer as a line on a print invoice is taxed.

Subsection (e) carves out printer-to-printer work. Printing or typesetting done for another printer, where no tangible property changes ownership, isn't taxed. And a printer holding a current manufacturer's permit buys its own production materials exempt under subsection (f), like any other manufacturer.

Inserts, postage, and the out-of-state printer

Postage is treated differently from labor. Under subsection (d), a printer that prints on Post Office cards or envelopes collects tax on the sale to its customer unless the customer resells them, but separately stated postage is excluded from the taxable amount. That single detail decides whether a mailing's postage line gets taxed, so an invoice that buries postage in a lump sum has given something away.

Inserts turn on who keeps them. Under subsection (g), inserts the buyer keeps for its own distribution are taxable to the buyer. Inserts that become part of a newspaper sold to the public aren't taxable to the buyer, and inserts printed by or paid for by the newspaper publisher and sold as part of the paper aren't taxed either. Same piece of paper, different tax result depending on whether it rides inside the Sunday edition or sits in the buyer's stockroom.

Subsection (h) is the commercial-printer safe harbor. A vendor isn't required to register or collect Oklahoma tax solely because it contracts with an Oklahoma commercial printer, even if it owns property at the printer's premises, has employees there, or the printer handles in-state distribution. The rule cites the Sales Tax Code's nexus provision for that. The safe harbor protects the out-of-state vendor from a collection duty; it says nothing about the Oklahoma buyer's own tax.

Invoice four: the promotional giveaways

The campaign orders branded calendars and a box of trinkets to hand out at an event. These feel like marketing expense. For sales tax they're a purchase of goods, full stop.

OAC 710:65-19-3 says the sale of blotters or calendars to a purchaser who gives them to others as part of a general goodwill, sales promotion, or advertising campaign, apart from the purchaser's sale of other property or services, is a taxable sale to that purchaser. Nothing is resold, so the purchaser is the consumer.

The rule's second subsection catches the near-giveaway. Property the purchaser sends to others on receipt of a small sum to cover postage and handling, again apart from any real sale, is likewise a taxable sale to the purchaser. Charging a nominal handling fee doesn't convert the recipient into a retail customer and the purchaser into a reseller.

Invoice five: the mailing itself

Postcards then go to a mail house, which addresses them and drops them into the postal stream to recipients in several cities and a few other states. Which jurisdiction's tax applies to that printed matter?

OAC 710:65-18-6, effective in its current form May 11, 2012 according to the source note, answers with a definition and a procedure. "Advertising and promotional direct mail" is printed material delivered by mail whose primary purpose is to attract public attention to a product, person, business, or organization, or to sell one. "Other direct mail" is everything else, including billing statements, legally required mailings, and non-promotional newsletters sent to shareholders, customers, employees, or agents.

The purchaser's paperwork

A purchaser of advertising direct mail that doesn't hold a direct pay permit has to give the seller one of two things. The first is a Direct Mail Form, which stays in effect until revoked in writing and shifts the tax to the purchaser on a direct pay basis. The second is information showing the jurisdictions where the mail is delivered, which lets the seller collect tax according to where the pieces go; absent bad faith, the seller then has no further collection duty on those transactions.

If the purchaser hands over neither, subsection (c) sends the seller to the fallback in paragraph (5) of the general sourcing rule, OAC 710:65-18-3. That paragraph sources the sale to the location from which the tangible personal property was shipped. In practice that means a mail house that gets no jurisdiction data taxes the whole job as if every piece were delivered at its own dock.

A purchaser that documents direct pay authority skips both forms under subsection (d). We've written before about what an Oklahoma direct payment permit does and doesn't do; for direct mail it's the cleanest path for a buyer with mailings spread across many jurisdictions.

The exemption hiding in subsection (e)

Sales of "other direct mail" aren't taxable under the Oklahoma Sales Tax Code. Invoices, statements, and legally required notices go out untaxed. The whole question, then, is primary purpose. A monthly statement is other direct mail. A monthly statement with a half-page offer printed on the back is a document whose primary purpose someone will have to characterize, and the printer, the mail house, and the buyer may each characterize it differently.

Invoice six: digital marketing and web work

The last invoice covers the website refresh, social media management, and online ads. Two sources speak to it, with different weight.

First, the advertising rule, 710:65-13-1, expressly exempts advertising through the internet and electronic media. That's rule text, and it covers the online ad buy.

Second, the web development and social work rest on thinner ground. Responding to a June 2013 request, the Commission issued Letter Ruling LR-13-040 to a Texas-based agency with Oklahoma clients that had asked whether its digital marketing, website design and development, and social media consulting were taxable. The Commission's reasoning in that one published letter ruling was that sales tax reaches gross receipts from tangible personal property and the services the Sales Tax Code lists, that the Code exempts advertising through the internet and electronic media, and that the described services were neither tangible personal property nor a listed taxable service. The ruling added that the agency's own Oklahoma purchases of taxable property and services used to deliver that work are taxable, and that use tax applies to property bought out of state and brought in.

Letter rulings bind the Commission only as to the recipient, on the facts stated, and only while the law stays the same; the ruling says so itself. We covered the difference between letter rulings and declaratory rulings separately, and the hosted software ruling shows how far that reasoning has been stretched by others. Treat LR-13-040 as a window into how the Commission thinks, not as a rule you can hand an auditor.

What an auditor checks on the purchaser side

Most of the rules above tell sellers what to collect. The audit exposure in a marketing campaign usually sits with the buyer, because the buyer is the party that holds all six invoices and can see which ones carried no tax.

Use tax is the first stop. OAC 710:65-21-4 says tangible personal property bought outside Oklahoma and brought in for storage, use, or consumption is subject to use tax when the vendor wasn't required to collect sales tax where the purchase was made. The purchaser reports and pays it on the Commission's forms, unless the out-of-state vendor is one that collects. Brochures printed in another state and shipped to Oklahoma City for in-house distribution, and giveaways ordered from an online promotional-products vendor that didn't charge tax, are the two line items we'd expect an examiner to pull first.

In our experience the examiner's working assumption on a printed deliverable is that it's taxable until the file shows why it isn't. For a newspaper insert, that means proof it became part of a paper sold to the public rather than stock the buyer kept. For the agency bill, it means the invoice actually describes idea work and not a print job with an agency letterhead. For direct mail, it means a Direct Mail Form, a jurisdiction report, or direct pay documentation on file; without one of those, the seller's default sourcing isn't a defense for the buyer's other-state obligations, which subsection (c) of the direct mail rule says aren't limited by Oklahoma's default.

Honest airtime for the government's side: the structure is coherent. Oklahoma taxes goods and a defined list of services, exempts the sale of advertising space, and taxes the inputs. A buyer that strips tax off every campaign invoice by calling it all "advertising" is asking the exemption to cover printed matter the rules plainly tax, and an examiner who reclassifies a print run is reading 710:65-19-265 as written.

The practitioner's edge

What decides most of these files is that the same creative work changes tax character depending on the vehicle it rides in. Sold as agency idea work, it's untaxed. Sold as advertising space in a recognized newspaper or on a website, it's exempt. Sold by a printer as design and typesetting on a print invoice to a non-manufacturer, it's taxed. Nothing about the work changed; the invoice did.

A second wrinkle is the primary-purpose line in the direct mail rule. Billing statements are other direct mail and go out untaxed. The moment marketing asks accounting to add a coupon to the statement, the mailing's primary purpose becomes a judgment call, and the printer's and mail house's tax treatment of that run may diverge from what the buyer assumed. That's a question worth asking before the run, not after the notice.

If a campaign's invoices don't line up with these rules, or a Tax Commission examiner has started asking for the paperwork behind an untaxed print job, reach us through the contact page or our Oklahoma City office. Sorting the invoices into the right columns before the audit tends to cost far less than arguing about them afterward.

Sources

  1. OAC 710:65-13-1 - Exemption for sales of certain types of advertising (eff. 9/14/2018)
  2. OAC 710:65-19-2 - Advertising agencies
  3. OAC 710:65-19-265 - Printers
  4. OAC 710:65-19-3 - Vendors of tangible personal property employed for advertising
  5. OAC 710:65-18-6 - Sourcing of sales involving direct mail (eff. 5-11-12)
  6. OAC 710:65-18-3 - Sourcing of retail sales (general sourcing rules)
  7. OAC 710:65-13-190 - Newspapers and periodicals; taxable and exempt transactions
  8. OAC 710:65-21-4 - Use tax on out-of-state purchases
  9. Oklahoma Tax Commission Letter Ruling LR-13-040 (2013) - digital media services

This article is general information about Oklahoma, Texas, and federal law, not legal advice, and it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Facts matter; talk to a lawyer about yours.