ERC disallowed: anatomy of Letter 105-C and the two-year clock
Letter 105-C is the IRS form letter that tells an employer its Employee Retention Credit claim has been disallowed. The IRS describes it as "your legal notice that we disallowed, or denied, the ERC that you claimed." It's a short letter. The clocks it starts are quieter than most people expect, and the quiet is the problem.
We see these letters reach closely held Oklahoma employers who filed 2021 claims through a promoter. The owner remembers signing something. The CPA may never have seen the amended return. Then a letter arrives with a two-year fuse attached, and nobody is sure whose job it is to respond.
This piece takes the letter apart in the order things actually happen, from the first page through the suit deadline and the statutory changes that reshaped the area after July 4, 2025. Nothing here is advice for your claim. It's the map.
Step one: what Letter 105-C actually says
The letter identifies the tax period, the reason for disallowance, the decision date, your appeal rights, and the timeframe for filing suit. The IRS explains that it disallows a claim "because we determined the business is ineligible or if the claim for credit or refund was untimely."
Those are two very different letters wearing the same number. An eligibility disallowance means the IRS looked at the substance and concluded the employer didn't qualify for the quarters claimed. A timeliness disallowance means the IRS isn't reaching the substance at all; the sample language on the IRS page reads, "We can't allow your claim for Employee Retention Credit (ERC) because it was filed after Jan. 31, 2024."
The first thing we do with any 105-C is figure out which kind it is. The response strategy, and sometimes whether any response is worth making, turns on that distinction.
The date on the letter beats the date you read it
That two-year period runs from the mailing of the notice, not from receipt. If the letter went to a promoter's address or a former bookkeeper, the clock started anyway. Write the letter date down first.
Step two: the 30-day ask
The letter asks you to respond within 30 days if you disagree. The IRS phrases this carefully: "We generally ask that you dispute the disallowance within 30 days to help protect your two-year timeline to request an appeal or file suit."
Notice what that sentence does and doesn't say. Thirty days isn't a statutory deadline to dispute. It's the IRS's suggested timing, offered so that the back-and-forth has room to finish before the real deadline arrives. Miss the 30 days and you haven't lost the claim. You've just spent a month of a two-year budget.
The IRS page lists what a dispute should contain: an explanation and documentation addressing the stated reason, support for at least one eligibility ground for each quarter, a description of the business's operations, the worksheets used to compute the credit, and a statement that the calculation excluded wages that can't count. In our experience, these are often the documents a promoter never asked for.
After a response, the IRS may write back asking for more information or saying the initial disallowance stands. Either way, the two-year clock keeps running through the correspondence.
Step three: Appeals, and what it doesn't buy you
The letter offers an appeal to the IRS Independent Office of Appeals. Appeals is the part of the IRS that reviews disputed cases separately from the people who made the original decision. The IRS says you "can also request an appeal at any time within two years of the disallowance letter," and you can request it when you send your dispute or afterward.
Here is the sentence we'd underline before any eligibility rule: "Requesting an appeal doesn't extend this time."
Taxpayers reasonably assume that once a case is "in Appeals," the government has paused the deadline. For a refund claim, it hasn't. The statute itself says that any "consideration, reconsideration, or action by the Secretary with respect to such claim" after the notice is mailed "shall not operate to extend the period within which suit may be begun." An Appeals conference that starts in month 20 and drags into month 25 can end with the claim dead on arrival, no matter how the conference was going.
So the question isn't whether to appeal. It's whether the appeal can finish inside the window, and if not, what to do about the window itself.
Step four: the two-year suit deadline
The governing rule is 26 U.S.C. § 6532(a). It sets both ends of the litigation window for refund suits. No suit may begin "before the expiration of 6 months from the date of filing the claim" unless the IRS decides sooner, and no suit may begin "after the expiration of 2 years from the date of mailing by certified mail or registered mail" of the notice of disallowance.
On the IRS page, the practical version reads: "Generally, you have two years from the date of Letter 105-C (your original claim disallowance) to file suit," in the U.S. District Court with jurisdiction or the U.S. Court of Federal Claims.
These are refund suits, not Tax Court deficiency cases; the employer is the plaintiff asking a court to order the government to pay. And the IRS says it can't issue a refund or allow a credit after the two-year period unless suit was filed within it. The deadline isn't a hurdle to litigation. It's the point past which the claim can't be paid by anyone.
Because these claims ride on amended employment tax returns, the dispute sits on top of the most sensitive tax account a closely held company has. If you've read our piece on where payroll tax penalties start, you know why we treat anything touching Form 941 as an owner-level issue.
Step five: Form 907, the extension people miss
Section 6532(a)(2) allows the two-year period to be extended "for such period as may be agreed upon in writing between the taxpayer and the Secretary." The IRS form for that agreement is Form 907, Agreement to Extend the Time to Bring Suit.
The IRS has set out when it will consider one for an ERC disallowance: you responded to the notice, you're awaiting a reply, and "there are 6 months or less remaining in the two-year period to file suit." The signed form goes in through the Document Upload Tool, selecting notice "CP320B" from the menu. A CP320B notice may have prompted this, but the IRS states that "taxpayers may be eligible even if they don't receive CP320B."
Then the line that matters: "The extension is not valid until the IRS signs it." You wait for a countersigned copy. An unsigned Form 907 sitting in an upload queue on the two-year anniversary protects nothing.
Think of it like a lease renewal. Sending the landlord a signed renewal doesn't keep you in the building; the landlord's signature does, and it has to be on the paper before the old term ends. The IRS has said it will consider these agreements, which is a real accommodation. It hasn't said it will sign every one, and it can't sign one after the period has expired.
In practice we'd want the dispute file complete and the extension request moving as soon as the six-month window opens, so the only open question is the signature.
Step six: Letter 106-C, the partial disallowance
Letter 106-C, Claim Partially Disallowed, is the same animal for a claim the IRS allowed in part. The IRS's guidance mirrors the 105-C page almost word for word: "Send your dispute within 30 days to help protect the two-year timeline," two years from the letter date to file suit, "Requesting an appeal doesn't extend this time," and a written extension "which needs to be signed by the taxpayer and the authorized IRS representative before the two-year period expires."
The trap here is complacency. Money arrived, the owner files the letter as good news, and the disallowed portion's two-year fuse burns from the same date.
Step seven: the statutory bar for late 2021 claims
This is where the government-favorable side of the story deserves honest airtime, because it's the law now and it's not a close question.
P.L. 119-21, enacted July 4, 2025, added a provision (section 70605(d)) stating that "no credit under section 3134 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 shall be allowed, and no refund with respect to any such credit shall be made," after enactment, "unless a claim for such credit or refund was filed by the taxpayer on or before January 31, 2024." By its own terms, that rule applies to credits and refunds allowed or made after the date of enactment.
The IRS's fact sheet, FS-2025-07, explains the scope. The bar reaches only claims for the third and fourth quarters of 2021 (the quarters governed by section 3134). Claims filed on or before January 31, 2024, aren't affected by it. For later-filed claims, the IRS states that, effective July 4, 2025, no new ERCs claimed on a return for those periods will be allowed or refunded.
Two refinements from the same fact sheet matter. A return is treated as filed on time "if the claim was postmarked and properly mailed or submitted to the appropriate IRS office" by that date, so proof of mailing can decide a case. And an amended return that withdraws an ERC claimed earlier isn't blocked by the provision; the IRS will process the withdrawal.
Why did Congress draw the line there? The same section creates a penalty for "COVID-ERTC promoters" who fail due-diligence requirements: "a penalty of $1,000 for each such failure," treated like the existing preparer due-diligence penalty, for aid provided after July 4, 2025. Congress was responding to the promoter-driven wave of claims. Some were legitimate, some were not, and the statute doesn't sort them; it sorts by filing date. An employer with a strong eligibility case for late 2021 that filed in February 2024 is simply out. A timeliness 105-C for those quarters is usually a letter to understand, not a letter to fight.
Step eight: the longer assessment clock on the government's side
The same law rewrote section 3134(l). For amounts attributable to a credit claimed under that section, the assessment period "shall not expire before the date that is 6 years after the latest of" three dates: the date the original return for the quarter was filed, the date the return is treated as filed under section 6501(b)(2), or "the date on which the claim for credit or refund with respect to such credit is made." The amendment applies to assessments made after July 4, 2025.
Read that against the ordinary assessment statutes, which generally give the IRS three years. Because "the date the claim is made" can be well after the original return, an employer that was paid and considers the matter closed may still be inside the government's window for years. Exposure doesn't run in only one direction, which is why we read a 105-C alongside the employer's whole payroll-tax posture for 2020 and 2021.
Step nine: withdrawal, for claims still in the queue
Separate from disputing a disallowance, the IRS describes a process to withdraw an ERC claim. All of the following must apply: the claim was made on an adjusted employment tax return (Forms 941-X, 943-X, 944-X, or CT-1X); that return was filed only to claim the ERC; the employer wants to withdraw the entire claim; and the IRS hasn't paid it, or paid it but the check hasn't been cashed or deposited.
The consequence is clean: "Claims that are withdrawn will be treated as if they were never filed." If the adjusted return is under audit, the request goes through the examiner or in response to the audit notice rather than the ordinary channel.
Withdrawal is for an employer that has come to doubt its own claim before the money is spent. It doesn't reverse a disallowance, and we're not stating whether any window for it is open or closed; confirm that against current IRS guidance when it matters.
How the pieces fit for an Oklahoma employer
Put the clocks side by side. The 30-day response is a courtesy window. The Appeals request can come any time within two years but pauses nothing. The two-year suit deadline runs from the mailing date and ends the claim if nothing is filed. Form 907 can move it, only in writing, only before expiration, and only once the IRS has signed. The six-year assessment period runs the other way. And for late-filed third- and fourth-quarter 2021 claims, the January 31, 2024 bar sits over everything.
The questions we'd ask first are about the record, not the merits: the exact letter date, the reason given, the quarters, whether any response went in and when, whether a promoter still holds a power of attorney, and how much of the two years is left. On that last point, our piece on Form 2848 versus Form 8821 explains why controlling who speaks to the IRS for the company matters before a dispute starts.
One thing this article doesn't address is the Oklahoma return side. A federal payroll credit that's allowed, disallowed, or repaid can affect items on state filings, and we didn't source Oklahoma's treatment here. Have your preparer check it rather than assume it follows the federal result.
Roughly, a lawyer becomes cheaper than the mistake when the letter is an eligibility denial with real money behind it, when the two-year window is under a year, or when the employer's larger payroll-tax picture for 2020 and 2021 is also in question.
If a Letter 105-C or 106-C has reached your company and the clock is already running, we'd welcome a conversation about where it stands. You can reach our practice through the contact page or our Oklahoma City office. Sorting out the timeline early is almost always less costly than discovering it late.
Sources
- IRS: Understanding Letter 105-C, Disallowance of the Employee Retention Credit
- IRS: If you receive Letter 106-C about the Employee Retention Credit
- 26 U.S.C. § 6532 - Periods of limitation on suits (LII)
- 26 U.S.C. § 3134 - Employee retention credit, with P.L. 119-21 § 70605 notes (LII)
- IRS FS-2025-07: FAQs on Employee Retention Credits under ERC compliance provisions of the One, Big, Beautiful Bill
- IRS: Withdraw an Employee Retention Credit (ERC) claim
This article is general information about Oklahoma, Texas, and federal law, not legal advice, and it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Facts matter; talk to a lawyer about yours.